"He's actually the third-choice right-back for Real Madrid." Jamie Carragher isn't mincing words about Trent Alexander-Arnold's Bernabéu adventure, and the numbers back him up.
Since his €10 million move to Madrid in June 2025 — just before his Liverpool contract expired — the 28-year-old has managed 22 starts in his first season, got left out of England's World Cup squad, and under José Mourinho has been benched for four of the last six matches. In Sunday's 2-1 El Clásico win at Barcelona, he played a handful of minutes. That's it.
Carragher didn't dress it up: "I think he made a big mistake."
Third choice at the Bernabéu
The situation is genuinely strange. Mourinho is fielding a midfielder at right-back, Denzel Dumfries — nominally the first choice — came on as a substitute in El Clásico, and Alexander-Arnold is sitting further down the pecking order than that. When a club is playing you that sparingly, the message isn't subtle. They want him gone.
Whether Liverpool would actually move for him is another question. Carragher thinks they should. "We've definitely missed his creativity," he said, pointing to Liverpool's ongoing problems at full-back. Ronald Araújo has been solid, but the creative output Alexander-Arnold provided from right-back — the switches, the through balls, the set-piece delivery — hasn't been replaced. That gap has real tactical consequences, and it affects Liverpool's ability to break down low defensive blocks, which is exactly where creativity from deep matters most.
A reunion would be fascinating from a betting standpoint too — Liverpool's attacking output odds shift considerably depending on whether that right-back position becomes a genuine creative outlet again or stays a defensive placeholder.
Meanwhile, Jacquet is quietly solving a different problem
While the Alexander-Arnold debate simmers, Liverpool's other defensive storyline is more straightforwardly positive. Jérémy Jacquet, signed for £60 million in the summer after both Alexander-Arnold and Ibrahima Konaté left for Madrid, has slotted in beside Virgil van Dijk and already looks like an upgrade.
Carragher's take on the partnership was striking: "It almost feels like he's the first center-back who's starting to look after Virgil a little bit rather than the other way around."
That's a meaningful shift. Van Dijk is still playing well, but at his age he can no longer be expected to carry a defensive unit. Eight Premier League games in, Jacquet is showing he doesn't need carrying. That frees Van Dijk to just play his own game — read, position, lead — without having to compensate for a partner still finding his feet.
- Trent Alexander-Arnold: third-choice right-back at Real Madrid, benched four of last six games
- 22 starts in his debut season at the Bernabéu, omitted from England's World Cup squad
- Jérémy Jacquet signed for £60 million after Konaté also departed for Real Madrid
- Carragher: Jacquet already looks like an upgrade on every previous Van Dijk partner
"I already feel he's an upgrade on everybody else Virgil's played alongside," said Carragher. Eight games is a small sample. But sometimes you can just tell.
