Cavan Sullivan is the youngest MLS MVP finalist ever — and the debate about whether he deserves it is missing the point

Last updated:
Content navigation
Cavan Sullivan is the youngest MLS MVP finalist ever — and the debate about whether he deserves it is missing the point.

"I wanna be a Ballon d'Or contender. I wanna win it. I want to be the best player in the world. If you think it's too much of a pipe dream, I don't really care."

Cavan Sullivan said that in April 2025. He was 15. He had played fewer than a dozen professional matches. The internet did exactly what the internet does. But here's the thing — nobody's laughing now.

Sullivan is now a finalist for the Landon Donovan MLS MVP award. The youngest in the history of the prize. The first teenager to make the shortlist. Nine goals and 14 assists in 1,828 minutes — a shade under two-thirds of a full season. Those are numbers that beat out Timo Werner, Luis Suarez, Denis Bouanga, Emil Forsberg, Thomas Müller, Antoine Griezmann, and Carles Gil in the assists column. He's one behind Son Heung-min and Marcos Reus. Lionel Messi — the actual best player in MLS — only has three more.

He probably won't win it, and that's fine

Messi is the MVP. The stats back it, the eye test backs it, and the other finalists — Hany Mukhtar, Guilherme, Evander — have all played considerably more minutes than Sullivan this season. There's also a legitimate argument that Pep Biel, Charlotte FC's league-leader in assists who played every single game, deserved a spot ahead of someone who only became a true regular after the Club World Cup. Same goes for Petar Musa's 22 goals for FC Dallas, or Griezmann's 22 goal contributions while dragging a struggling Orlando City side to relevance.

MVP voting isn't a pure spreadsheet exercise — players, club staff, and media each hold a third of the vote. Sullivan's story carries weight in those rooms, and that's not entirely wrong. The football backs him up.

The dangerous game, though, is extrapolating. If Sullivan produced those numbers in 59% of available minutes, what does a full season look like? Roughly 14 goals and 21 assists — a league-leading assist tally, with only Messi ahead on total contributions. Compelling. Also completely speculative. Mo Salah broke Premier League records in 2024-25 and then his numbers dropped sharply without warning. Son, who posted nine goals and three assists in just 10 MLS matches last season, has only found the net seven times across the whole of this one.

Hot streaks exist. Sample sizes lie. Sullivan himself picked up an ankle knock in late October and was forced off after a heavy challenge in the final regular season game — a match in which he still scored twice, for what it's worth.

What actually matters now

Philadelphia Union are in the playoffs. They are, to put it plainly, an inconsistent team. When Sullivan is threading assists to Milan Ilopski and the midfield holds its shape, they look like genuine contenders. When they don't, they look like a 2-1 home loss to New England — their first-round playoff opponent. That result, at the end of October, was a warning.

Sullivan's playoff performances will say more about his ceiling than any MVP vote. This is where the cockiness either becomes currency or gets exposed. The minutes are accumulating. The knocks are appearing. First-round playoff series against New England is not the stage where you want your best player running on fumes.

Beyond this season, Sullivan joins Manchester City when he turns 18. How the next few weeks go won't determine that move — but they'll sharpen everyone's read on just how ready he is for what comes after. The Union need him. The question is whether the kid who said those words about the Ballon d'Or shows up when the stakes are actually on the table.

Nothing he's done this season suggests he'll wilt. But that's what everyone thought about the last American teenager we crowned too early.

Swain Scheps.
Author
Last updated: November 2026