"I feel the obligation to almost apologize for the state of the pitch." That's a head coach speaking after a quarterfinal win — not a defeat. That tells you everything about what happened at Sports Illustrated Stadium last Sunday.
Gotham FC beat the Seattle Reign 1-0, booked a semifinal against Kansas City Current, and walked off a field that looked more like a neglected training ground than an NWSL playoff venue. Sand residue from a rugby doubleheader still lined the pitch. Faint rugby markings were visible. Reign captain Jess Fishlock called it "atrocious." Reign coach Laura Harvey used a word that doesn't get printed. Gotham midfielder Jaelin Howell said the surface felt "sandy" and "unstable." Gotham attacker Jaedyn Shaw worried her planted foot would slip during corner kicks.
By Monday, Gotham had pulled the plug. Sunday's semifinal against the Current moves to Icahn Stadium — a 5,000-seat venue on Randall's Island where Gotham have played exactly twice before. Sports Illustrated Stadium seats 25,000. That's not a cosmetic downgrade; it's a gut punch for a home playoff run that the players earned.
The Landlord Problem
Here's where it gets uglier. The pitch at Sports Illustrated Stadium isn't Gotham's to manage — they're secondary tenants to MLS' Red Bull New York. RBNY installed the new surface back in July and it has since hosted 17 or more matches, including a rugby doubleheader on October 30 that left the kind of scars you'd expect.
Gotham raised concerns before their November 1 home game against the Royals. Nothing changed. The NWSL then fined Gotham $10,000 for the state of the field — a field they don't control. The NWSL Players Association wasn't even aware of the fine. Neither, reportedly, was RBNY. Laura Harvey mentioned it in a post-match press conference and that's how most people found out.
A FIFA-standard clearance from an NWSL-appointed consultant on Friday didn't settle anything. The players who actually ran on it had a different verdict.
Gotham and the NWSL explored two remedies: re-sodding the pitch entirely or a hybrid model stitching artificial threads into the existing grass. The hybrid option might have been ready in time for Sunday's game. The stumbling block? RBNY have a friendly against Club América on Saturday — a dead-rubber end-of-season game during the men's international break — and couldn't guarantee the work would be completed in time for that match. RBNY refused to proceed. So Gotham left.
RBNY will play their Club América friendly on the same surface NWSL players called unplayable. No changes planned.
A Structural Issue the NWSL Can't Paper Over
This isn't a one-off embarrassment. Around half the NWSL's clubs are secondary tenants in stadiums they don't run, which means a men's preseason friendly can outrank a women's playoff semifinal in the scheduling pecking order. That's the reality — not a surprise, just rarely this visible.
The Washington Spirit faced their own venue chaos this postseason, nearly shifted to an NFL stadium they'd never played in before MLS' D.C. United and a sponsor contribution from Lafayette Federal Credit Union salvaged Audi Field. Boston Legacy have been displaced from Gillette Stadium for home games. The Kansas City Current — owners and operators of their own purpose-built CPKC Stadium — are the benchmark the rest of the league is measured against, and even they kicked off a quarterfinal at 11:30 a.m. local time because of broadcast slot logistics.
Gotham are moving to Etihad Park in 2028, but that venue will be managed by NYCFC. Secondary tenants again. The cycle continues.
- Gotham FC vs Kansas City Current NWSL Semifinal moves to Icahn Stadium, Randall's Island
- Kickoff: Sunday, 3 p.m. ET on ABC
- Icahn Stadium capacity: approximately 5,000 — compared to Sports Illustrated Stadium's 25,000
- NWSL fined Gotham $10,000 for pitch conditions at a venue they don't manage
- RBNY's Club América friendly on Saturday was the deciding factor in blocking pitch repairs
Gotham captain Tierna Davidson framed the move as a decision the club had no good options on: "A smaller stadium means many of you will not be there, and that is the hardest part of this decision." Coach Juan Carlos Amoros, for his part, complimented Icahn Stadium's surface when Gotham used it for a Concacaf W Champions Cup group stage game last August. So at minimum, the players will have a surface they can trust.
The Current, meanwhile, arrive as the team that owns their own house. That's not an irrelevant detail heading into a semifinal — it's the structural advantage the rest of the league is still chasing.
