Manchester United Sacked Carrick. The Actual Problem Is What They Did Last Summer.

Last updated:
Content navigation
Manchester United Sacked Carrick. The Actual Problem Is What They Did Last Summer..

"I expect more. 100%. I expect more from our technical director." Lisandro Martínez said the quiet part loud after the 2-0 loss to Atlético Madrid. Less than a month later, Michael Carrick was gone — and nothing fundamental has changed.

Mauricio Pochettino is lined up. United sit 18th in the Premier League, their lowest position this late in a season since the 1980s. One win from their last 11, and that single victory came against newly promoted Ipswich back in August. This is not a manager problem that a manager can fix.

Carrick's start had been genuinely promising — back in January he won 12 of 17 league matches, finished third, and returned the club to the Champions League. That form earned him the full-time job. What unravelled this summer was always coming, though. Playing just 40 matches in 2025-26 without European football flattered both the squad's depth and its fitness. The return to a full continental schedule exposed exactly what the summer window should have addressed.

Three midfielders, three problems left unsolved

Manchester United spent $190 million this summer. All of it on midfielders — Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos, Youri Tielemans. None of them bad signings. None of them solving what actually needed solving.

Left back remains a liability. Luke Shaw at 31 was always a fitness gamble, and it hasn't paid off. Patrick Dorgu is better in advanced positions. Dalot and Mazraoui have long since burned through any patience as makeshift options. Lewis Hall signed a Newcastle extension without United making a serious push, and Alejandro Balde was a bench player at Barcelona — genuinely gettable — and apparently not gettable enough to pursue.

Centre-back is arguably worse. Harry Maguire at 33 has run out of road. Martínez and De Ligt can't stay fit. Yoro and Ayden Heaven are depth pieces at best at this stage. United have conceded 30 goals across all competitions so far this season — only Lens in Europe's big five leagues has let in more. Ezri Konsa went to Arsenal for $67 million. Nathan Collins and Jarrad Branthwaite were available for serious but acquirable fees. Marcos Senesi moved to Tottenham from Bournemouth for free. Free.

Then there's left wing. Carrick flagged it publicly as an area needing depth. Mbeumo and Amad are well set on the right. The opposite flank? Marcus Rashford hasn't scored or assisted in eight appearances since returning. Cunha and Mount are central midfielders wearing winger costumes. Antonio Nusa was lighting up the Bundesliga — four goals, seven assists in nine games — and RB Leipzig would reportedly consider offers around €70 million. Victor Muñoz went to Liverpool. Iliman Ndiaye moved to City. United watched.

No striker cover, no plan

Šesko's injury has left United with Joshua Zirkzee and nobody else as a recognized center forward. Jean-Philippe Mateta was available, would not have blocked Šesko long-term, and brings the kind of Premier League physicality United are crying out for. Nicolas Jackson, now thriving at Aston Villa, was also on the market. He's exactly what United needed — a mobile, pressing striker who can carry a team through a congested schedule.

Both are playing elsewhere. Zirkzee is not.

Pochettino inherits a squad that is structurally broken in multiple positions, managed by a director of football and CEO who spent $190 million without touching the roster's most obvious wounds. Martínez put it plainly: as players, they need to do more. But building "a strong squad to be ready" is not a player's job. That part has been failed. The betting market will shorten on relegation survival odds — rightly so. Switching the manager is the easy answer. United have been giving themselves easy answers for years.

Steve Ward.
Author
Last updated: November 2026