Nicky Butt Unleashes on 'Bluffer' Martínez: 'I'd Take Him Straight Out'

Last updated:
Content navigation
Nicky Butt Unleashes on 'Bluffer' Martínez: 'I'd Take Him Straight Out'.

"That lad's a bluffer, full stop." Nicky Butt didn't ease into it. The former Manchester United midfielder went on Football Uncensored and said out loud what a growing number of Old Trafford supporters are clearly thinking — Lisandro Martínez needs to go.

The trigger was Saturday's 2-0 loss at Chelsea, where Martínez capped a wretched October by conceding a penalty for an elbow and getting himself sent off. Not a rash challenge under pressure. A deliberate foul that left ten teammates to deal with the fallout.

"He threw it in with that elbow because that was the most obvious thing anyone could do," Butt said. "The reason why he did it is because he's not strong enough to defend properly."

A month that's cost Martínez everything

It's been a spectacular unravelling. Earlier this month, Martínez was outmuscled by Dominic Solanke — a striker, not exactly known for bullying centre-backs — who scored a stoppage-time equaliser. Then came the post-match interview where the Argentine publicly criticised the club's board for failing in the transfer window, singling out director of football Jason Wilcox by name.

He was fined. He kept his starting spot. Then he got sent off at Stamford Bridge.

Butt's case isn't just about the red card. It's about the sequence. A player who told the world his teammates weren't good enough, who challenged fans to knock on his front door after critical comments, who waved an Argentine flag at the World Cup while based in England — and is now producing performances that don't come close to justifying any of it.

"He has now gone from someone the fans love to someone the fans loathe and want out of their football club," Butt said. "He's absolutely killed himself."

What comes next — and what it means on the betting sheet

Martínez will miss Sunday's home fixture against Aston Villa through suspension, though he's eligible for Tuesday's Champions League match against AS Roma. United arrive at that game on a nine-game winless run. A defender who conceded a penalty and walked in his last outing isn't exactly the stabilising presence Michael Carrick's side needs in Europe right now — United's clean sheet odds in both fixtures just got noticeably worse.

Whether Butt's words carry any weight in the boardroom is another matter. But the argument itself is hard to dismiss: Martínez publicly undermined his club, his manager, and his teammates — and then played his way into a suspension. "If he was going to go and buy players," Butt noted, "he'd be careful because he's the first one they'd replace."

That's not really a line you can argue with right now.

Last updated: November 2026