"If it is true, then it is probably not the first mistake Ratcliffe and co have made." That was Norway manager Stale Solbakken, taking aim at Manchester United's ownership from a press conference podium — and he's not wrong to raise an eyebrow.
The timeline here is damning. While reports of a done deal with Mauricio Pochettino were circulating, Michael Carrick was still turning up at Carrington to run training sessions for players not away on international duty. He hadn't been told he was out. He was just... still there, doing his job, while his bosses sat in Monaco deciding his future.
Ratcliffe's Monaco gathering
The decision came after Jim Ratcliffe met with CEO Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox on the Wednesday. Berrada then flew back and delivered the news to Carrick in person the following Thursday. By that point, Pochettino's imminent arrival had already been reported the day before. Carrick almost certainly knew what was coming before anyone official said a word.
Solbakken's reading of it was straightforward: "It says a bit about what kind of club man he is. How strongly he is connected to that club and what loyalty he has." High praise for Carrick. A quiet indictment of everyone above him.
Gary Neville was less quiet. The former United captain called it "spectacularly bad" and went further: "To be in Monaco as an executive and an owner whilst your manager, who's a club legend, is taking training on the pitch and simultaneously approaching the US Soccer Federation to approach Mauricio Pochettino — it's just quite simply disgusting." He used the phrase constructive dismissal. That's not hyperbole from Neville, that's a legal framing of what actually happened.
What this means for United under Pochettino
The irony is that Carrick had just overseen a dramatic comeback draw against Aston Villa and a two-goal turnaround win over Roma in Europe. The football wasn't the problem. The optics, the communication, the basic professional dignity extended to a club legend — that's what collapsed.
Pochettino still hasn't been officially announced. He's currently committed to managing the United States through a two-legged CONCACAF Nations League quarter-final against Haiti. Until that's done, United are in limbo — and the manner in which they got here already has pundits, rival managers, and players across Europe forming their opinion of Ratcliffe's regime.
"The optics of being in Monaco whilst the team, the staff, the people who are running the club on a day-to-day basis are in Manchester, it's just not good," Neville said. Hard to argue with that. For a club trying to signal a new era of serious, professional leadership, this was a poor advertisement.
