Balogun Is Back on the Scoresheet — But Has He Done Enough for a USMNT Return?

Last updated:
Content navigation
Balogun Is Back on the Scoresheet — But Has He Done Enough for a USMNT Return?.

Folarin Balogun hasn't started a league game since May 17. He's managed 116 minutes of Ligue 1 football all season. And yet, 20 minutes after coming off the bench against Paris FC on Sunday, he redirected a driven cross into the net to open his 2026-27 account. Same instincts. Same timing. Just severely underused.

It wasn't enough to save Monaco — they lost 3-1 — but that's almost beside the point. For a player who's spent the last two months at the margins of everything, just being relevant again matters.

A summer that turned sour fast

Balogun earned his reputation the hard way at the World Cup. Three goals in four games, consecutive group stage wins for the first time since 1930, the USMNT's first knockout victory in 24 years. He was the tournament's breakout American story.

Then it unraveled. A controversial red card in the round of 32 against Bosnia and Herzegovina, followed by a FIFA reversal that dragged his name into a political firestorm with ties to the White House. The USMNT subsequently got dismantled 4-1 by Belgium, and Balogun — without doing anything wrong — became the face of a scandal that overshadowed everything he'd earned.

Two months later, a Deadline Day move to Everton collapsed after a failed medical. The fallout disrupted transfer deals across Europe. Two other players lost their moves because of it. He stayed at Monaco, spooked and presumably grateful to be out of the headlines.

A minor leg injury kept him out of September-October's international camp. Five substitute appearances for Monaco were all he had to show for the new season going into Sunday. Low profile doesn't begin to cover it.

Pochettino's call — and why it's genuinely complicated

USMNT boss Mauricio Pochettino names his November roster in the coming days, with camp starting November 9. Balogun's inclusion is a real question, not a formality.

The case against calling him up is straightforward: 116 minutes of football, no starts, still battling Paris Brunner for Monaco's No. 9 spot. Pochettino already left him home last month for those exact reasons, and one goal in a losing effort doesn't dramatically change the arithmetic.

The case for it is simpler than it looks. Balogun is still the best pure striker the USMNT has. One goal, one game back, and the mechanics are clearly still there.

What complicates the decision is how well things went without him. Teenage forwards Julian Hall and Justin Ellis combined for five goals across four friendlies on their senior debuts last camp. That's not a small thing. Pochettino now has a legitimate reason to keep the momentum going with players who are actually match-sharp — and a legitimate reason to ease Balogun back at club level before stacking international minutes on top.

If Balogun gets the nod, his World Cup pedigree alone makes him a player to factor into any USMNT betting markets. If Pochettino leaves him out again, that tells you something about where the manager's head is at — and how much runway Hall and Ellis are actually being given.

One goal. Two months of absence. A roster spot that's no longer guaranteed. Balogun's got some ground to make up.

Last updated: November 2026