Kyle Martino Wants Emma Hayes to Coach the USMNT — and the USWNT at the Same Time

Last updated:
Content navigation
Kyle Martino Wants Emma Hayes to Coach the USMNT — and the USWNT at the Same Time.

"This isn't clickbait. This is a conversation starter." That's how Kyle Martino framed his suggestion on TNT Sports that Emma Hayes — current USWNT head coach and Olympic gold medallist — should also take charge of the USMNT following Mauricio Pochettino's departure to Manchester United.

Not just the men's team. Both. At the same time.

It's the kind of idea that gets dismissed in five seconds if you're not paying attention. But Martino wasn't throwing it out for a reaction. He made a structured case: Hayes is one of the best coaches operating in world football right now, her international schedules largely don't overlap, she already has a strong relationship with U.S. Soccer, and her public profile gives the federation something most coaches simply can't offer.

The credentials aren't in question

Twelve years at Chelsea. Seven Women's Super League titles. Then she arrived with the USWNT in May 2024 — two months before the Paris Olympics, with a squad still bruised from the earliest exit in their World Cup history — and guided them through an unbeaten campaign to gold, beating Brazil 1-0 in the final. She was awarded the inaugural Women's Johan Cruyff Trophy for it.

That's not a soft résumé. That's the kind of track record that gets you shortlisted for any coaching job in the world.

Martino also tied the idea to something broader. "Equal pay, we did that for players — equal opportunity, let's do that for coaches." Whether you buy that framing or not, it at least gives U.S. Soccer a reason to engage with the idea beyond the gimmick factor.

Why it's genuinely complicated

There's an obvious snag: Hayes is currently sitting on the search committee tasked with finding Pochettino's replacement. Martino's answer is straightforward — remove her from the committee and consider her as a candidate instead.

Less straightforward is what this would mean for the USWNT's own cycle. The 2027 Women's World Cup is approaching, and walking away from that project — or splitting focus across two national programmes — would be a decision Hayes would have to make with full awareness of the competitive cost. The Americans are rebuilding momentum after years of turbulence. That's not a project you abandon lightly.

For the USMNT's side of the ledger, the market has already thrown out names like Pep Guardiola, though reports suggest he's inclined to step back from coaching for now. Landon Donovan and Tim Howard have both been skeptical about whether Guardiola would even be the right fit for the American setup. So the field is genuinely open.

Hayes may not end up anywhere near the men's job — practically or politically. But Martino has at least forced a question U.S. Soccer probably wasn't expecting: is the person already leading one of their national teams the most qualified candidate for the other?

Vitory Santos
Author
Last updated: November 2026