"Our guide for the types of managers that we would consider is not based on the level of fame or celebrity." That's U.S. Soccer COO Dan Helfrich, speaking Thursday — and it's either a genuinely mature approach to a coaching search, or a very elegant way of saying they can't afford Pep Guardiola.
Mauricio Pochettino left for Manchester United this week, ending a tenure that was more turbulent than the original hire suggested it would be. Now U.S. Soccer is looking for a replacement, and Helfrich insists they won't be stampeded into a headline grab. What they want, he said, is "a very high standard of excellence, and ambition, and talent, and experience, and belief."
Fine words. The question is whether the process backs them up.
The search is already moving — quietly
Formal interviews haven't started, but agents and representatives have already contacted U.S. Soccer to pitch their clients. Helfrich confirmed that early-stage discussions are underway, and that the groundwork actually began before Pochettino even handed in his notice. The federation runs succession planning meetings roughly every other month to monitor available coaching talent — not just free agents, but anyone who could theoretically qualify. When the vacancy opened, Helfrich said, there was "no chaos or panic."
The search is being led by Helfrich and CEO JT Batson, with input from USWNT coach Emma Hayes, assistant sporting director Oguchi Onyewu, and others. Batson and U.S. Soccer president Cindy Parlow Cone are travelling to Europe this weekend for FIFA Congress, which will inevitably double as a networking opportunity. Expect conversations in December to shape the timeline considerably.
There's no hard deadline, but the practical one is obvious: the USMNT plays Mexico in a Concacaf Nations League semifinal in March. U.S. Soccer would prefer a permanent appointment by then. It's not mandatory — Steve Cherundolo is in as interim and will take charge of the December camp, capped by a friendly against Jamaica — but walking into a Nations League knockout game without a confirmed head coach is not ideal preparation for a home World Cup in 2026.
American or not? Helfrich won't be drawn
The nationality debate is already simmering. Bruce Arena made his position clear earlier this year: an American coach understands the culture, the pride, the environment. An outsider, in his view, doesn't. Pochettino himself admitted he faced "resistance" — resistance he believed was partly about not being American.
And yet, Sebastian Berhalter said recently that Pochettino "made us even more proud to be American." Helfrich leaned on that. He pointed to Emma Hayes — a Brit who has completely won over the USWNT — as evidence that alignment on ambition and understanding of what American soccer means can come from "many different types of personal backgrounds."
It's a reasonable argument. It's also one that will only be tested when we see who actually gets the job. The search is open geographically, in terms of league background, salary range, and nationality. That's either refreshingly open-minded or dangerously vague, depending on how the next few months go.
One thing Helfrich was explicit about: donors have no seat at this table. Billionaire Ken Griffin contributed funds to support the Pochettino hire. That won't be repeated as a process. The money may still come — philanthropic investment in the national team program is expected to continue — but the decision-making stays internal.
The Nations League odds for a U.S. team heading into March without settled leadership look shakier by the week. Whoever takes this job inherits a squad with genuine talent and a World Cup on home soil in less than two years. The pressure to get the appointment right is real. "We'll move at the pace that the situation dictates," Helfrich said. That's a reasonable position — until it isn't.
