NWSL's Stadium Saga Is More Than an Embarrassment — It's a Competitive Problem

Last updated:
Content navigation
NWSL's Stadium Saga Is More Than an Embarrassment — It's a Competitive Problem.

"I would say it's inexcusable," said Gotham FC midfielder Midge Purce. She's right. And the fact that she had to say it at all — in a playoff semi-final week — tells you everything about where the NWSL still stands.

Gotham were forced to abandon their home at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, after the pitch was deemed unsafe following widespread criticism from the quarter-final against Seattle. Players from both teams called it "atrocious" and "so bad." Seattle coach Laura Harvey was blunter: "no way a playoff game should be played on that shit." So Gotham relocated to Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island — a 5,000-seat facility built in the early 2000s that is charming in its own way, but is emphatically not a postseason venue for a league that bills itself among the world's best.

Two semi-finals, two embarrassments

Gotham weren't alone in their misery. Down in Washington DC, the Spirit nearly ended up at the NFL's Northwest Stadium — a cavernous, soulless venue that would have swallowed the occasion whole. They share Audi Field with DC United, who had already committed the ground to a Division III college football game on Saturday. Only last-minute negotiations allowed the Spirit to play there at all. The result: a nationally broadcast NWSL semi-final played on a field still marked with American football lines.

Gotham coach Juan Carlos Amorós put the broader frustration plainly: "You sit down to watch that game around the world and you're seeing those American football lines... this league deserves better."

He's not wrong. And it matters beyond optics. Gotham were unbeaten in 13 home matches at Sports Illustrated Stadium this season. They lost on Sunday. They didn't register a single shot on target — for the second playoff match in a row. Kansas City advance to the final. Whether the venue change was decisive is unknowable, but Amorós called it "part of the sadness," and that's hard to dismiss when a team that was nearly unplayable at home all year suddenly can't create a chance in a postseason knockoff venue.

The infrastructure gap won't fix itself

Kansas City Current can speak from a position of comfort here — they own their stadium, one of a handful of NWSL clubs who do. Current coach Chris Armas acknowledged the "noise" around the situation while pointing to the league's growth curve: "Stadiums are going to come, facilities are going to be built. But everything has to catch up — and we're not there."

That's a fair point, but it lands differently when you're the team that didn't have to move.

Gotham are set to move into Etihad Park — NYCFC's future home — in 2028. Even then, they won't own it. The Spirit's situation at Audi Field, where DC United effectively hold the keys, clearly isn't resolved either. These aren't freak occurrences. They're structural. And in a league whose competitive balance and quality of play has genuinely improved, the gap between the product on the pitch and the infrastructure surrounding it is becoming harder to ignore.

Purce put it simply: "We're supposed to be one of the best leagues in the entire world. I think it's a bad look for everyone involved."

Steve Ward.
Author
Last updated: November 2026