"At this level, in this kind of game, as a league, we should be having a better surface." That was Gotham FC head coach Juan Carlos Amorós — not complaining about the opposition, but about his own home pitch. That quote tells you everything about where the NWSL's most successful club currently stands.
The 2026 NWSL semifinals, as a logistical exercise, were a mess. Washington Spirit stay at Audi Field after a last-minute buyout of a college football game involving a credit union. Gotham FC, the league's No. 1 seed and Shield winners, host their first-ever semifinal at Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island — a 5,000-seat track-and-field venue — because Sports Illustrated Stadium's pitch is essentially falling apart.
How the Spirit pulled it off
When Washington went 3-0 up on Portland at halftime, the front office started making calls. Spirit president of soccer operations Haley Carter pushed CEO Kim Stone. Owner Michele Kang signed off. The target: keep the game at Audi Field, where the Spirit average 15,152 fans and have built one of the most intimidating home atmospheres in American women's football.
The problem was the Secretaries' Cup — a Division III college football game between the Coast Guard Academy and the Merchant Marine Academy, booked at Audi Field for Saturday since August. One source called what came next a "Hail Mary." The Spirit proposed buying it out. Shared sponsor Lafayette Credit Union stepped in to cover the cost, estimated in the low six figures. Deal done.
The semifinal against Utah Royals now kicks off at noon Saturday, runs its course, and then college football teams take the field. The Spirit were so eager to announce it they wanted confirmation by full-time against Portland. Instead, they had to wait while Gotham's situation played out.
Gotham's venue nightmare has no clean ending
Sports Illustrated Stadium's pitch had large bare patches, visible holes near the corner flags, and was sandy enough that Jaedyn Shaw slipped taking corners — including the one that deflected in for the only goal against Seattle. A referee was spotted filling a hole with turf before a corner was taken. This is a quarterfinal in the country's top women's league.
Gotham had tried to fix it. They offered to pay for reseeding. A field consultant cleared it to FIFA standards on Friday. But after Saturday's Red Bulls vs. Atlanta United MLS game added more wear, any margin for error evaporated. By Monday, three options were on the table: repair Sports Illustrated Stadium, play at Icahn Stadium, or accept Kansas City Current's offer to host the game at their purpose-built CPKC Stadium — which would have stripped Gotham of home advantage entirely. That last one was never going to fly for a No. 1 seed.
The repair option died when it became clear hybrid stitching the pitch couldn't be guaranteed in time without risking the Red Bulls' own Saturday game. Icahn Stadium it is.
- Gotham were fined $10,000 for field conditions after their Nov. 1 home game against Utah — two days after a USA Rugby doubleheader tore up the pitch they don't actually control
- The club leases Sports Illustrated Stadium from Red Bulls ownership and bears financial responsibility for conditions despite having no authority over the event schedule
- Icahn Stadium holds 5,000 people; Gotham regularly draw far more than that at their home ground
- Beginning in 2028, Gotham move to Etihad Park, a purpose-built 25,000-capacity stadium, where they'll have significantly more scheduling influence
Gotham's supporters group Cloud 9 said they were "deeply disappointed" but backed the move to protect players. That's the right call. It doesn't make it any less grim that the league's best team this season is hosting a semifinal in a venue with fewer seats than many lower-league grounds in England.
What this means structurally for the NWSL is obvious: clubs that don't control their infrastructure are always one scheduling conflict away from exactly this kind of chaos. The Spirit are still figuring out their own long-term situation at Audi Field. Gotham have a plan from 2028 onward. For everyone else sharing venues with MLS sides or other tenants — and potentially navigating MLS's upcoming shift to a fall-to-spring calendar — the problem is only going to get more complicated before it gets better.
Gotham governor Carolyn Tisch Blodgett put it plainly: "Our players deserve a playing surface that meets the standards of a professional semifinal, and our fans deserve the opportunity to support them. We have worked tirelessly to deliver on both and are disappointed that we cannot."
