Balogun Breaks Silence on Everton Transfer Collapse: 'I Didn't Feel Comfortable to Sign'

Last updated:
Content navigation
Balogun Breaks Silence on Everton Transfer Collapse: 'I Didn't Feel Comfortable to Sign'.

Folarin Balogun flew to Everton with a contract in hand. He left without signing one. That's the story, and he's finally telling it.

"I flew to Everton, obviously, with a set contract," Balogun said at USMNT camp on Thursday. "And then by the time I left, the contract was changed. So that was the situation, in short. The contract was changed, and then in the end, I didn't feel comfortable to sign."

It's the first time he's addressed it publicly. The Athletic had previously reported that issues arose during his medical, triggering a renegotiation of terms. Balogun didn't dig into those specifics, but his version is clear enough: he showed up expecting one deal and was handed another. He walked.

From World Cup spotlight to Monaco's quiet

What makes this more than a standard transfer saga is the timing. Balogun arrived at that Everton negotiating table as one of the more talked-about American footballers on the planet — fresh off a red card at the World Cup that somehow made him famous, appearances on morning shows, Fanatics Fest, the whole circuit. He had leverage, or thought he did.

Instead, he ended up back in Monaco. A club that draws around 8,000 fans per home game, in a league most Americans don't watch. He's played 233 minutes of competitive football since the summer — one start, six substitute appearances, one goal. He was left out of Monaco's UEFA Conference League squad entirely before being added as a replacement for the injured Ansu Fati.

Not exactly what he had in mind.

"From almost being on the biggest of stages to going back to Monaco, which is fairly quiet," he said, "it's been different." He's also lost his place in the starting eleven — injury played a part, but he acknowledged there were "a lot of things that happened at Monaco out of my control."

He's already eyeing the exit again

Balogun is back with the USMNT for Concacaf Nations League games against Haiti this week, and by his own account, the camp has done him good. "Coming back with the boys, and being a part of something, gives me a new sense of energy, a new sense of life," he said.

That renewed energy matters for the national team, which needs Balogun functioning properly ahead of a home World Cup. A striker playing 233 minutes across six months is not the striker Pochettino — or whoever coaches them by then — can build around.

  • Balogun has scored just one goal since the World Cup
  • He's made only one start for Monaco this season
  • He was initially excluded from Monaco's Conference League squad
  • He missed the USMNT's September-October camp entirely

After the Nations League games, he heads back to Monaco for the rest of the calendar year. But probably not much longer than that. The reasons he wanted out in the summer haven't changed — the contract fiasco just delayed the inevitable.

"I'm sure, in the upcoming transfer windows," he said Thursday, "I'll look to leave again."

Nick Mordin.
Author
Last updated: November 2026