MLS Power Rankings After Decision Day: Nashville's Record Season and What the Playoffs Actually Look Like

Last updated:
Content navigation
MLS Power Rankings After Decision Day: Nashville's Record Season and What the Playoffs Actually Look Like.

Nashville SC just had the best regular season in MLS history. Three losses all year. Twenty-five goals allowed — the fewest since the league moved to a 34-game schedule in 2012. A new points record. If you're making a MLS Cup market right now, you're starting with Nashville and working backwards.

Cristian Espinoza deserves more credit than he's getting. Nashville identified a need, signed him, and watched him put up 4 goals and 15 assists — his fifth straight MLS season with double-digit assists. He's three away from 100 career assists in the league. That's not luck. That's Nashville's front office doing something genuinely straightforward and genuinely rare: finding a good MLS player for a position they needed to fill.

The West Belongs to Vancouver — For Now

Vancouver Whitecaps are the West's favorites and the underlying numbers back it up hard. Per American Soccer Analysis' expected points metric, only 2019 LAFC, the 2014 Galaxy, and 2018 Atlanta United have posted better underlyings over a full season since 2013. Their expected goal differential per game is second-best in that entire span.

The post-World Cup drop-off is real — 32 points from 20 games is still elite, but it's not what they were doing in the first half. That slight softening is the only reason to hesitate before backing them in the West.

Inter Miami, meanwhile, are a legitimate puzzle. They blew a 3-0 first-half lead against Charlotte on Decision Day and drew 3-3. In the second half of the season, six Eastern Conference teams outpointed them. Now they draw red-hot Columbus in Round One — a Crew side that went 8 wins from 9 matches under interim coach Laurent Courtois after Henrik Rydstrom was dismissed in May. Miami can absolutely win it all again. They can also flame out in the first round. Both feel equally plausible.

The Chaos Bracket: Orlando vs. Cincinnati

The Wild Card match between Orlando City and FC Cincinnati might be the most genuinely unhinged fixture of the entire playoffs. Between the two sides: 130 goals scored, 153 allowed across the season. Orlando tied the MLS record for goals conceded. Cincinnati finished ninth for a reason despite Evander's 14 goals and 17 assists.

Antoine Griezmann carried Orlando to the postseason — 14 goals and 8 assists in just 18 matches. That's the kind of output that keeps leaky defenses alive in cup football. Evander is exactly the match-winner you want in a single-elimination format. Something has to give in that fixture, and the odds on a high-scoring chaos match look very reasonable.

Elsewhere in the standings: FC Dallas are having their best season in a decade, with Petar Musa's 22 goals leading the attack. Philadelphia Union are the most dangerous six-seed in recent memory — nobody has had better post-World Cup underlying numbers — but they lost to New England two weeks ago and now have to go there for Round One. LAFC and Houston are both limping in. LAFC managed two wins in their final 16 matches. Houston has two wins in their last 14. St. Louis ended a four-match losing streak on Decision Day and get a few weeks off before facing LAFC. That rest might matter more than people are pricing in.

At the bottom: Toronto have missed the playoffs every year since 2020 and parted ways with Robin Fraser. Atlanta's second Tata Martino era has 22 points from 20 post-World Cup matches and no clear answers. CF Montréal finish with the Wooden Spoon. Sporting KC avoided it — new DP André Luiz scored eight times in 12 starts, which counts as a win given the rest of their year.

Vitory Santos
Author
Last updated: November 2026