The EFL has had enough of clubs taking shots at each other online. Chief executive Trevor Birch sent a formal letter to all 72 club chairs and executives warning them to rein in their social media teams — and the trigger was hard to miss: Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney jumping out from behind a tree in a barely-disguised dig at Southampton's spying scandal.
The skit, framed as a Firefox privacy ad ahead of Wrexham's league fixture against Southampton in September, was textbook Reynolds — sharp, funny, deniable. McElhenney tagged in with the line about preventing spies from seeing what you're doing. Southampton manager Tonda Eckert wasn't laughing. "You can imagine that the whole situation is not particularly funny for me," he told BBC Radio Solent. Hard to argue with that.
What Spygate actually cost — and why Wrexham have every right to be bitter
To understand why Reynolds and McElhenney went there, you need the full picture. Southampton's analyst intern was caught recording Middlesbrough's training session from behind a tree ahead of last season's Championship playoff semifinal. The Saints were charged but allowed to play on, winning the tie 2-1 on aggregate. Then, four days before the playoff final, they were thrown out entirely — replaced by Middlesbrough. Hull won the final. Southampton have since admitted to spying on Ipswich Town and Oxford United as well.
Wrexham finished seventh. One place outside the playoff spots. Had Southampton been expelled before the postseason began, the Red Dragons would have had a legitimate shot at Premier League promotion. That's not a minor footnote — that's a franchise-altering consequence for a club owned by two Hollywood actors whose entire project is built around climbing the English football pyramid.
So yes, the tree joke landed differently if you're sitting in the Wrexham boardroom.
No saints in this social media war
Birch's letter is careful to avoid singling anyone out — and rightly so. Southampton themselves fired back on social media when Wrexham were fined for fielding two ineligible players. Birmingham City took their own swing at the Saints too. This has become a pattern across the league, not an isolated incident.
"While any one post may be viewed as an isolated lapse, taken together they risk creating a culture in which short-term engagement is prioritized over judgment, responsibility and long-term reputation," Birch wrote.
He's not wrong, but the EFL's credibility on this is complicated. Clubs wouldn't be throwing punches on Instagram if the governing body had handled Spygate more decisively from the start. The chaotic timeline — letting Southampton play, then ejecting them four days before a final — is what created the resentment. The social media posts are a symptom. The mismanagement of last season's playoff process is the disease.
Whether the warning changes anything is another matter. Reynolds built a career on knowing exactly where the line is and parking himself right on it. The Firefox ad will get more engagement this week than Birch's letter ever will.
